Thin Mints

Thin Mints // Pale Yellow

Remember this baking fail?  I’ve had others.  One was over a year ago when I tried to make homemade thin mints.  After my success of homemade Tagalongs, I was ready to conquer all the Girl Scout cookies.  One bad batch defeated that dream and it took me a year to try my hand at Girl Scout cookies again.

Thin Mints // Pale Yellow

I’m glad I tried again.  Perseverance is an important character trait and one I think the Girl Scouts can get behind.  Not only does this recipe only require three ingredients; but because of its simplicity, I used the opportunity to try a new baking technique.

Thin Mints // Pale Yellow

That is right, I tempered chocolate.  And guess what, it makes a difference.  The chocolate was so smooth, hard, and shiny.  Tempering chocolate isn’t as difficult as I thought, it just requires a little extra time: melt all the chocolate in a double boiler until it reaches 110 F and then remove from the heat.  Stir and cool until the chocolate is 80 F.  The chocolate will start to firm up, it’s ok, just keep stirring.  Place the chocolate back on the double boiler and heat to 90 F, stirring the whole time.  Keep the chocolate at 90 F while dipping.

Thin Mints // Pale Yellow

However many times I dip things in chocolate, I never get better at it and the process continually annoys me.  Making these thin mints with the tempered chocolate was a dream!  These cookies taste pretty close to the real thing.  They are crispy and minty and look exactly like the Girl Scout version.  The thin mints are perfect right out of the freezer.

Thin Mints // Pale Yellow

One Year Ago – Tie Dye Cupcakes

Print the Recipe!

Thin Mints

Adapted from Top with Cinnamon

Yield – 30 cookies

15 oreos {possibly a lot more}

10 ounces bittersweet chocolate

1 teaspoon mint extract

  1. Split apart the oreo and scrape out the cream filling.  My box had a lot of broken pieces, so out of the whole box, I was only able to get 30 unbroken halves.

  2. Temper your chocolate following these directions from Mark Bittman via The Kitchn:

    1. Add your chocolate to a bowl set above just simmering water.

    2. Stir and melt the chocolate. Bring the temperature up to 110 F.

    3. Remove the chocolate from the heat and bring the temperature down to 80 F.

    4. Place the chocolate back on the simmering water and bring the temperature up to 90 F.  Keep the chocolate at 90 F.

  3. Stir in the mint extract.

  4. Dip each oreo half in the chocolate to coat using a fork.

  5. Place on parchment paper and let harden at room temperature.

Thin Mints // Pale Yellow


Filed under Cookies

7 responses to “Thin Mints

  1. Great recipe! Love your passion. You’re right, tempering is the big key. Looking at the pix, I wonder if it might help you to slow the cooling process (to reduce the cacao butter separation). I saw your note about eating them direct from the freezer — you might already know this, but if you temper and put choc in the freezer, it will make the white marks. If you slow that cooling process down, eg room temperature, then fridge – you will reduce the likliehood of the white marks. Have FUN! Keep going!

    • Thanks for the tips and the encouragement! I didn’t place the thin mints in the freezer to cool faster, I just prefer to eat them frozen.

      Great to know about slowing down the cooling process to reduce the white stripes, I wondered where they had come from. I let the chocolate cool slowly on the counter top. Hopefully practice will make perfect!

      Sent from my iPad

  2. Pingback: Graham Crackers | Pale Yellow

  3. Pingback: Mallomars | Pale Yellow

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s